Exploring How Canadians Use Retirement Savings to Buy Homes

In Canada, there is a program called the Home1.38% to keep up with the dollar value of growth
Buyers Plan that allows home purchasers to withdrawthat the $25,000 at 8% would return over a 15 year
a maximum of $25,000 from their retirement savingsperiod. Historically, house values have appreciated in
accounts (known as an RRSP accounts) on a taxCanada at least 3% per year nationally, suggesting
free basis and repay those funds over the course ofthat people who invest in a house will be more than
15 years. The funds must be used toward thetwo times better off.
purchase of a new home and the buyers must notOf course, there are other arguments to be made.
have used this program in the past unless the allOne would be the matter of making mortgage
proceeds have been repaid for more than 5 years.payments and paying a lot of interest on that
The question that many Canadians have whenmortgage. The alternative would be rent which,
deciding whether to use the Home Buyers Plan toalthough cheaper than a mortgage payment, would
come up with their minimum 5% down payment isresult in no equity being built. After all, in the example
whether it makes sense to forfeit the future growthabove, total mortgage interest over 15 years would
on their investments and invest, instead, in a home.amount to $195,923 assuming a fixed rate of 6%.
Without question, pulling out of a market-basedStill, unless rent can all inclusive for an extremely
investment that yields even as much as 8% per yearminimal amount, home ownership seems to have its
on a compounded basis makes sense to invest in thefinancial benefits.
housing market. To illustrate this example, consider aLastly, there are many social and sociological benefits
home buyer who intends on using the $25,000 into owning one's own home. Even if it means
their retirement account to purchase a house forwithdrawing tax-free from a retirement account and
$275,000.repaying that amount over a fifteen year period, the
Even after paying mortgage default insurance fees,financial benefits far outweigh the disadvantages... by
that property would have to grow in value justa large margin.